Showing posts with label worlds longest cable stayed bridge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label worlds longest cable stayed bridge. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Tacoma Bridge Disaster

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxTZ446tbzE

The Tacoma Bridge Engineering Disaster has been a turning point which had saved a lot of lives and making bridge engineering a lot safer.

The original Tacoma Narrows Bridge was opened to traffic on July 1, 1940. It was located in Washington State, near Puget Sound.
The Tacoma Narrows Bridge was the third-longest suspension bridge in the United States at the time, with a length of 5939 feet including approaches. Its two supporting towers were 425 feet high. The towers were 2800 feet apart.
Design
Prior to this time, most bridge designs were based on trusses, arches, and cantilevers to support heavy freight trains. Automobiles were obviously much lighter. Suspension bridges were both more elegant and economical than railway bridges. Thus the suspension design became favored for automobile traffic. Unfortunately, engineers did not fully understand the forces acting upon bridges. Neither did they understand the response of the suspension bridge design to these poorly understood forces.
Furthermore, the Tacoma Narrows Bridge was built with shallow plate girders instead of the deep stiffening trusses of railway bridges. Note that the wind can pass through trusses. Plate girders, on the other hand, present an obstacle to the wind.
As a result of its design, the Tacoma Narrows Bridge experienced rolling undulations which were driven by the wind. It thus acquired the nickname "Galloping Gertie."
Failure
Strong winds caused the bridge to collapse on November 7, 1940. Initially, 35 mile per hour winds excited the bridge's transverse vibration mode, with an amplitude of 1.5 feet. This motion lasted 3 hours.
The wind then increased to 42 miles per hour. In addition, a support cable at mid-span snapped, resulting in an unbalanced loading condition. The bridge response thus changed to a 0.2 Hz torsional vibration mode, with an amplitude up to 28 feet. The torsional mode is shown in Figures 1a and 1b.
Figure 1a. Torsional Mode of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge
Figure 1b. Torsional Mode of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge
The torsional mode shape was such that the bridge was effectively divided into two halves. The two halves vibrated out-of-phase with one another. In other words, one half rotated clockwise, while the other rotated counter-clockwise. The two half spans then alternate polarities.
One explanation of this is the "law of minimum energy." A suspension bridge may either twist as a whole or divide into half spans with opposite rotations. Nature prefers the two half-span option since this requires less wind energy.
The dividing line between the two half spans is called the "nodal line." Ideally, no rotation occurs along this line.
The bridge collapsed during the excitation of this torsional mode. Specifically, a 600 foot length of the center span broke loose from the suspenders and fell a distance of 190 feet into the cold waters below. The failure is shown in Figures 2a and 2b.
Figure 2a. Failure of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge
Figure 2b. Tacoma Narrows Bridge after the Failure
Failure Theories
Candidates
The fundamental weakness of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge was its extreme flexibility, both vertically and in torsion. This weakness was due to the shallowness of the stiffening girders and the narrowness of the roadway, relative to its span length.
Engineers still debate the exact cause of its collapse, however. Three theories are:
1. Random turbulence
2. Periodic vortex shedding
3. Aerodynamic instability (negative damping)
These theories are taken from Reference 1. Aerodynamic instability is the leading candidate.
Random Turbulence
An early theory was that the wind pressure simply excited the natural frequencies of the bridge. This condition is called "resonance." The problem with this theory is that resonance is a very precise phenomenon, requiring the driving force frequency to be at, or near, one of the system's natural frequencies in order to produce large oscillations. The turbulent wind pressure, however, would have varied randomly with time. Thus, turbulence would seem unlikely to have driven the observed steady oscillation of the bridge.
Vortex Shedding
Theodore von Karman, a famous aeronautical engineer, was convinced that vortex shedding drove the bridge oscillations. A diagram of vortex shedding around a spherical body is shown in Figure 3. Von Karman showed that blunt bodies such as bridge decks could also shed periodic vortices in their wakes.
A problem with this theory is that the natural vortex shedding frequency was calculated to be 1 Hz. This frequency is also called the "Strouhal frequency." The torsional mode frequency, however, was 0.2 Hz. This frequency was observed by Professor F. B. Farquharson, who witnessed the collapse of the bridge. The calculated vortex shedding frequency was five times higher than the torsional frequency. It was thus too high to have excited the torsional mode frequency.
In addition to "von Karman" vortex shedding, a flutter-like pattern of vortices may have formed at a frequency coincident with the torsional oscillation mode. Whether these flutter vortices were a cause or an effect of the twisting motion is unclear.
Figure 3. Vortex Shedding around a Spherical Body
Aerodynamic Instability
Aerodynamic instability is a self-excited vibration. In this case, the alternating force that sustains the motion is created or controlled by the motion itself. The alternating force disappears when the motion disappears. This phenomenon is also modeled as free vibration with negative damping.
Airfoil flutter and transmission line galloping are related examples of this instability. Further explanations of instability are given in References 2 , 3, and 4.
The following scenario shows how aerodynamic instability may have caused the Tacoma Narrows Bridge to fail. For simplicity, consider the motion of only one span half.
Assume that the wind direction was not perfectly horizontal, perhaps striking the bridge span from below, as shown in Figure 4a
Thus, the bridge is initially at an angle-of-attack with respect to the wind. Aerodynamic lift is generated because the pressure below the span is greater than the pressure above. This lift force effectively places a torque, or moment, on the bridge. The span then begins to twist clockwise as show in Figure 4b. Specifically, the windward edge rotates upward while the leeward edge rotates downward.

The span has rotational stiffness, however. Thus, elastic strain energy builds up as the span rotates. Eventually, the stiffness moment overcomes the moment from the lift force. The span then reverses its course, now rotating counter-clockwise
The span's angular momentum will not allow it to simply return to its initial rest position, however. The reason is that there is little or no energy dissipation mechanism. Thus, the span overshoots its initial rest position. In fact, it overshoots to the extent that the wind now strikes the span from above as shown in Figure 4c. The wind's lift force now effectively places a counter-clockwise moment on the span.
Once again, strain energy builds up in the span material. Eventually, the stiffness moment exceeds the moment from the wind's lift force. The span thus reverse course, now rotating clockwise. Again, it overshoots its rest position. The cycle of oscillation begins anew from the position shown in Figure 4a, except that the span now has rotational velocity as it passes through the original rest position.
The cycles of oscillation continue in a repetitive manner.
Note that the wind force varies as a function of the span angle during the cycle. The wind force may also vary with the angular velocity. The wind force is not a function of time, however.
Eventually, one of two failure modes occurs. One possibility is that the span experiences fatigue failure due to an excessive number of stress reversals. The other is that the angular displacement increased in an unstable manner until the material is stressed beyond its yield point, and then beyond its ultimate stress limit.
In reality, these two failure modes are interrelated. For example, accumulated fatigue effectively lowers the yield and ultimate stress limits. Regardless, the bridge collapses.
As a final note, the aerodynamic instability oscillation is not a resonant oscillation since the wind does not have a forcing frequency at, or near, the bridge's torsional mode frequency. Some physics and engineering textbooks mistakenly cite the Tacoma Narrows Bridge as an example of resonance. This problem is discussed in Reference 5.
Nevertheless, the bridge's collapse remains the most well-know structural failure due to vibration.
Replacement Bridge
A new Tacoma Narrows Bridge was built in 1950, as shown in Figure 5. The second bridge had truss-girders which allowed the winds to pass through. It also had increased torsional stiffness because it was thicker and wider. Furthermore, wind tunnel testing was performed to verify the design of the new bridge prior to its construction.
References
1. James Koughan, "The Collapse of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, Evaluation of Competing Theories of its Demise, and the Effects of the Disaster of Succeeding Bridge Designs," The University of Texas at Austin, 1996.
2. Den Hartog, Mechanical Vibrations, Dover, New York, 1985.
3. H. Bachmann, et al., Vibration Problems in Structures, Birkhauser Verlag, Berlin, 1995.

4. M. Levy and M. Salvadori, Why Buildings Fall Down, Norton, New York, 1992.

5. K. Billah and R. Scanlan, "Resonance, Tacoma Narrows Bridge Failure, and Undergraduate Physics, Textbooks;" American Journal of Physics, 1991.

Figure 5. The Replacement Tacoma Narrows Bridge, Built in 1950

Monday, May 4, 2009

Sungai Johor Bridge


Expand Image Expand Image

http://en.structurae.de/files/photos/f007925/sungai_johor.jpg

The Sungai Johor Bridge will definitely be the longest cable stayed bridge in Malaysia

The cable-stayed bridge has a single central plane of cables in a harp configuration.

Construction of the cable-stayed bridge across the Johor River began in 2006; the bridge was first planned in 1996 but the Asian currency crisis put paid to it at the time. The bridge will connect Kong Kong on the western bank to Teluk Sengat in the east.

The preliminary and detailed design and engineering work was carried out by COWI Consulting Engineers and Planners AS and Ranhill Consulting Sdn Bhd for Senai Desaru Expressway Berhad (the concession holder). Three Ranhill engineers spent six months in Denmark with COWI designers to develop the design of the bridge.

The construction was undertaken by Ranhill Engineers and Constructors Sdn Bhd, foundations were constructed by Ranhill Antara Koh Sdn Bhd, the steel construction was the remit of Jawala and MBEC. Waiko Engineering Sdn Bhd are construction subcontractors, the stay cables and incremental launching of sections were contracted to VSL International.

"The new road will be a four-lane dual carriageway and will improve access across the region of Johfor."

BRIDGE STRUCTURE

The main span of the bridge is 500m and the pylon height is 150m above the surface of the river. The cable-stayed design of the bridge is in a harp configuration but in a single central plane (only one set of stay cables). This means that the cables are in a near-parallel arrangement, by virtue of the fact that the cables are attached to various points on each of the two ‘A’ shaped concrete pylon towers.

Each tower has a foundation of 34-bore 2m-diameter steel cased piles. The result of this is that the height of attachment of each cable on the tower is similar to the distance from the tower along the roadway to its lower attachment.

The middle 739m of the bridge has a composite deck with a 250mm-thick precast concrete deck slab and a closed structural steel skirt (3.5m deep). There are two 484.5m deck sections on either side of the central section and these consist of a concrete box girder structure.

Friday, May 1, 2009

Worlds Longest cable-stayed bridge span is completed

Photo: COWI

The worlds longest cable stayed bridge was officially opened on 30 June 2008.

The two cantilevers of China's Sutong Bridge have been connected, creating the world's longest cable-stayed bridge span. COWI has provided construction management on the project, among other services.

China's Sutong Bridge crosses the Yangtze River upstream from Shanghai. Its 40-metre wide bridge deck will carry a six-lane road plus emergency lanes. The main span of the bridge is 1088 metres, making it the longest cable-stayed bridge in the world.

COWI is providing services that include design assistance and design review, design of scour protection, aerodynamic investigations, construction control and construction management.

Photo: COWI

http://english.people.com.cn/200704/24/images/0423_C78.jpg

http://www.dormanlongtechnology.com/images/Sutong_PC_01.jpg

The Sutong Bridge, China, close to completion.
Image gallery

Ahead of schedule

COWI chief project manager Lars Thornfeldt Sørensen has been with the project since it began in 2003.
He says, "The project has run smoothly and the closure of the main span was completed nine months ahead of schedule. The significant volume of river traffic could have been a major problem but the Chinese authorities organised timed closures to allow for the hoisting of bridge girder segments."

The final bridge segment connecting the two spans was floated down river and hoisted into place at the beginning of June.

Long cantilevers

The connection of the bridge cantilevers is more than just a ceremonial occasion. Prior to connection, the two record long cantilevers were sensitive to strong winds and therefore it was important to join the cantilevers before the beginning of the typhoon season. Joining them creates a far stronger structure.

Sutong Bridge

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2139/2158327196_931a633aa9.jpg

http://a.abcnews.com/images/Technology/nm_sutong_080702_ssh.jpg

http://en.structurae.de/files/photos/wikipedia/On_the_Sutong_Bridge_1.jpg